The
$200,000 Orchestra Musician
William
E. Ford, Ph.D., Atlanta Music Critic
Luchino
Discounti, AMC Digital Assistant
Recent contract settlements at several of America's major
orchestras have produced some impressive numbers. Percentage increases of 5
percent or 7.5 percent are easy enough to report, but percentages can obscure
what those increases mean in actual dollars.
So we decided to do a quick comparison.
This is not an analysis of whether orchestra musicians are
paid too much or too little, nor an attempt to determine what an exceptional
musician is "worth." We simply wanted to put recently negotiated
salaries and raises into a context that makes them easier to understand.
We looked at minimum salaries at five major orchestras and
compared both the negotiated increases and resulting salaries with mean wages
for all occupations in their metropolitan areas.
The Contracts
Contract settlements are usually reported as percentage
increases. But a 5 percent raise on a $165,000 salary and a 5 percent raise on
a $65,000 salary are very different amounts of money. Even reporting the
increase in dollars does not necessarily make its size immediately apparent.
We wanted a simple benchmark that would put those dollar
increases into perspective.
For each orchestra, we compared the total increase in
minimum annual salary over the contract with the mean annual wage for all
workers in the orchestra's metropolitan area. The comparison asks a
straightforward question: How large is the negotiated increase in annual salary
when measured against what the average worker in that community earns in an
entire year?
For example, if a contract raises a musician's annual salary
by $25,000 and the mean annual wage in that metropolitan area is $65,000, the
increase is equivalent to about 38 percent of an average worker's entire annual
earnings. This is not another way of calculating the musician's percentage
raise. It is simply a benchmark for understanding the magnitude of the dollar
increase.
We made a second comparison as well: the musician's final
minimum salary as a percentage of the MSA mean wage. That tells us where the
resulting salary stands relative to earnings in the surrounding labor market.
|
Orchestra |
Starting
minimum |
Final
minimum |
Increase |
Increase
as % of MSA mean wage |
Final
salary as % of MSA mean wage |
|
Cleveland |
$165,516 |
$191,620 |
$26,104 |
39% |
289% |
|
Philadelphia |
$176,280 |
$200,008 |
$23,728 |
33% |
279% |
|
Boston |
$203,580* |
$230,000 |
$26,420 |
29% |
257% |
|
New
York |
≈$154,000* |
$205,000 |
≈$51,000 |
≈59% |
237% |
|
San
Francisco |
$179,400 |
$205,920 |
$26,520 |
26% |
205% |
Boston's
starting figure annualizes its previous $3,915 weekly scale. New York is
approximate because published information provides the percentage increases and
final minimum rather than a precise starting figure.
The Cleveland agreement increases minimum annual
compensation by $26,104. That increase alone is equal to about 39 percent of
the mean annual wage of all workers in metropolitan Cleveland.
Philadelphia's $23,728 increase equals about 33 percent of
its MSA mean annual wage. Boston's $26,420 increase equals approximately 29
percent.
New York is the outlier. Its three-year settlement raises
the annual salary level by approximately $51,000, an amount equal to roughly 59
percent of the mean annual wage in the New York metropolitan area.
The Resulting Salaries
Comparing each orchestra's final minimum with its own
metropolitan mean wage provides a rough adjustment for differences among local
economies. A $200,000 salary in San Francisco exists in a very different
economic environment from a $200,000 salary in Cleveland.
On that basis, Cleveland is particularly striking. Its final
$191,620 minimum is the lowest of the five except by a relatively small amount,
yet compared with its surrounding labor market it is the highest: 289
percent of the MSA mean wage.
Philadelphia's $200,008 minimum equals approximately 279
percent of its metropolitan mean wage. Boston reaches 257 percent,
New York 237 percent, and San Francisco 205 percent.
Thus, even after placing salaries within their local labor
markets, minimum compensation at these orchestras ranges from about twice the
metropolitan mean wage in San Francisco to nearly three times the metropolitan
mean in Cleveland.
Note that these are salary minimums. They do not represent
concertmaster or principal compensation, and some musicians receive overscale,
seniority or other additional compensation.
Putting the Numbers in Perspective
None of these calculations tells us whether an orchestral
musician should earn $100,000, $200,000 or $300,000. That isn't the question we
set out to answer.
The purpose was simply to make some increasingly large
numbers easier to understand.
A Cleveland Orchestra musician's minimum salary will
increase by $26,104 over the new contract. That increase alone is equivalent to
nearly 40 percent of the mean annual wage in metropolitan Cleveland.
When the contract is fully implemented, the $191,620 minimum will approach three
times the metropolitan mean wage.
Philadelphia's minimum will exceed $200,000 and equal about 2.8
times its metropolitan mean wage. Boston will reach $230,000. New York and
San Francisco will also exceed $200,000.
This comparison does not tell us what the musicians are
worth, whether their contracts are justified, or whether one orchestra's
musicians are more "excellent" than another's.
It simply puts the negotiated salaries into perspective.
And at several of America's leading orchestras, $200,000
is rapidly becoming a useful number to keep in mind.
No comments:
Post a Comment